The circularity discussion is moving into product decisions
Footwear circularity is gaining a more practical design language. On September 3, 2026, Fashion for Good announced a Circularity Guidance Quick Sheet developed with circular.fashion through Closing the Footwear Loop. Its guidance addresses leather boots, running shoes and lifestyle sneakers, recognizing that different constructions need different approaches. [1]
For footwear companies, the useful change is the shift toward decisions made before production: how the shoe is assembled, how it is maintained and what can happen after its first period of use. Our interpretation is that sole development belongs in this conversation early. A material label alone cannot explain whether a shoe will last, be repaired locally or enter an available recovery system.
The most useful starting point is the customer’s reason for retiring a shoe. Is the outsole worn through, has a bond failed, or is the upper no longer serviceable? A repair strategy should address the actual failure pattern of the intended category. Discussing those possibilities during development can reveal which construction choices deserve attention and which proposed services are unlikely to help that product.

Repair is becoming part of the brand experience
Nike’s circularity update describes a September 23–29 Nike (Re)Play experience at Nike SoHo in New York. It brought together activities including repair, footwear cleaning, trade-in, vintage, recycling and donation. The company also describes targeted cleaning and repair initiatives; this should not be read as universal availability in every market. [2]
The business implication is that the customer relationship can continue after the original sale. Care instructions, accessible services and a clear repair route can support longer use. For a brand considering this model, start with the service customers can actually access. Identify who will inspect the shoe, which repairs are feasible and how the customer receives a realistic estimate of cost and outcome.
A service plan also needs a clear decision when a shoe cannot be repaired. Explain whether the customer can receive advice, use an available collection route or take the product back without further work. Set expectations before the shoe is sent away. A convenient booking process is helpful, but the customer’s experience ultimately depends on an honest assessment and a service that can be delivered locally.

Outsole replacement needs to be considered during design
A repair-oriented brief should ask whether the worn component can be replaced without destroying the rest of the shoe. Discuss how a repairer would access the outsole, what preparation is required and whether the upper and midsole are likely to remain serviceable. These are design questions to validate, rather than a claim that every construction is suitable for resoling.
The answer may differ between a leather boot and a lightweight athletic shoe. Have representative samples assessed by the intended repair partner before making customer-facing promises. Replacement-part availability also matters: a theoretically replaceable sole offers limited value if its compatible size, shape or material cannot be obtained when the customer needs it. Plan the service route alongside the original production order.
A useful development exercise is to ask a repair partner to work on a trial pair and document the steps involved. Review the time taken, the parts required and the condition of the shoe afterwards. If the proposed process is difficult or uneconomic, revise the plan before launch. This turns repairability from a design intention into something the team has examined in a realistic service setting.

Recycled content and end-of-life recovery are separate questions
Fashion for Good highlights the challenge created by footwear’s many components and mixed constructions. Its quick-sheet announcement explains why sorting, disassembly and recycling can be difficult. Nike likewise acknowledges that brand take-back programs alone cannot solve post-consumer waste. [1][2]
For sourcing teams, this suggests separating several claims. A sole may contain recycled input, a shoe may be repairable, and a local operator may be able to recover a particular material; none of those statements automatically proves the others. Request evidence for the claim being made, including the component involved and any geographic limits. Clear descriptions help buyers compare products and help customers understand the options available to them after wear.
Keep records that allow each claim to be checked later. For recycled input, ask which component the documentation covers and how the stated share is calculated. For a collection program, identify who accepts the product and what happens after collection. If the destination or processing route is still being developed, describe that stage accurately. Customers need a usable explanation of the program’s scope.

A practical starting point for brands and sole buyers
Select one shoe category and map its likely wear points. Then compare the proposed sole construction with the intended use, repair access, replacement supply and available recovery partners. Include the cost of service and spare parts in the commercial discussion. Keeping a shoe in use has to work for the customer as well as for the product team.
After launch, record common reasons for repair requests and compare them with the original development assumptions. If the same component repeatedly needs attention, use that information in the next product review. Also check whether spare parts are still available in the sizes customers need. The service can then inform future design and purchasing decisions, rather than operating as a separate activity with little connection to product development.
The near-term opportunity is a credible program with a clear scope: for example, a repair service for a defined collection in a named market. Avoid turning that into a broader promise without supporting evidence. When discussing a sole project with Huadong, include any goals for maintenance, replacement or material recovery in the initial brief so feasibility can be considered before the construction and tooling are finalized.

Frequently Asked Questions
Does recycled content make a shoe circular?
It describes one input choice. Product life, construction, repair access and an actual recovery route must be considered separately. Keep environmental descriptions specific to the evidence available for that component or program.
Can every shoe be resoled?
No. Feasibility depends on construction, condition, compatible parts and the repair process. A qualified repairer should assess representative samples. Confirm that suitable replacement parts and an accessible service partner will be available after sale.
Is footwear repair available everywhere?
Service access differs by brand, location and product. Verify the local offer before advertising a repair or take-back benefit. State any limits on collection, eligible products and the work that the service can undertake.
What should a brand ask its sole supplier?
Ask about expected wear, construction options, replacement-part compatibility and how proposed materials relate to the intended repair or recovery route. Share the intended service model early so the supplier can assess it alongside the product brief.
Sources
[1] Fashion for Good: Circularity Guidance Quick Sheet, September 3, 2026
[2] Nike: Advancing Circular Solutions, accessed November 17, 2026


